5 houses realtors hate to have to sell

Every agent has a story about the listing that aged them ten years in six weeks. The problem is rarely the square footage or the school district. It is the kind of house, and the way it is presented, that quietly turns a normal job into a grind. When you look at the patterns, there are a few types of homes that consistently make realtors groan when the phone rings.

If you are getting ready to sell, it helps to know which properties are the hardest to move and why. Once you see what pushes agents to the edge, you can decide whether you want to fix the issues, price around them, or at least stop blaming the person whose name is on the yard sign.

The overpriced “why won’t anyone love me?” house

The listing every agent dreads starts with a seller who insists on a fantasy price. You might feel your place is special, but buyers are looking at hard numbers, recent sales, and what else they can get for the same money. When a home is priced too high, it simply sits, day after day, while fresher listings leapfrog it. Over time, that long “days on market” counter becomes its own red flag, and the house turns into what pros call a stale listing that buyers assume has hidden problems or a difficult owner.

Agents see this pattern constantly. When a home has been on the market for months with no offers, experienced voices in seller and realtor forums point out that you are “over priced period,” which means buyers are not even considering scheduling a showing. Detailed guidance on pricing warns that Pricing a home too high is dangerous because Overpriced properties linger until the seller is forced into painful price cuts. Coverage of stale listings backs this up, noting that Listings often go cold because of unrealistic pricing, even when nothing is wrong with the structure. That is why seasoned agents on threads about whether to switch representation argue that it is likely NOT the agent’s fault when a clearly overpriced home does not move.

The messy, smelly, “lived-in” listing

The second kind of house that wears agents down is not cursed by the market, it is sabotaged by daily life. You might be used to the overflowing laundry basket, the cat box in the hallway, or the lingering smell of last night’s fried fish, but buyers are not. They are walking in with fresh senses and a mental checklist, and clutter or odor hits them before they even notice the countertops. Agents know that even great professional photos cannot save a place that looks and smells worse in person than it did online.

Multiple pros call out the same culprits. One breakdown of seller habits notes that it is harder to attract buyers if you cannot keep the house neat and clean, especially after you have paid for polished listing photos that promise something very different from reality, and bluntly reminds you that You need to tidy up before every showing. Another roundup of agent complaints says that, Aside from sellers hovering during tours, a messy house is one of the biggest frustrations, because buyers expect a basic level of cleanliness in every room. Pet issues are their own category: detailed advice on selling with animals warns that, Although pets are beloved, their odors can become a serious obstacle when it is time to sell, and lays out specific strategies for dealing with lingering smells that turn off visitors the second they step inside.

The “problem child” with hidden or scary defects

Some homes are tough to sell not because of how they look, but because of what is lurking behind the walls or under the yard. Structural issues, major systems at the end of their life, or health-related mysteries make buyers nervous and lenders cautious. When an inspection report starts flagging foundation cracks, roof trouble, or unexplained moisture, you are no longer just negotiating price, you are negotiating fear. That is the kind of listing that keeps agents up at night, because every new piece of information can blow up a deal that looked solid a week earlier.

Inspection specialists point out that the biggest red flags include foundation cracks, especially horizontal ones or those wider than one quarter of an inch, along with visible structural issues and roof problems like missing shingles or sagging, all of which show up as serious concerns in Sep inspection guidance. Separate advice on getting a home ready to sell warns that if the roof has significant issues, the property may not be insurable for the next buyer and the deal can fall apart entirely once the insurer or lender weighs in. On the health side, homeowners have described situations where a new place triggered a persistent, unexplained headache, a Mystery that made it impossible to move in for months. Add in the legal landmines, like septic system failures, Solar leases that confuse buyers, or a Failure to disclose issues on a Seller Property Disclosu form, and you have a recipe for lawsuits that risk dragging the agent into court as well.

The legal and paperwork nightmare house

Even when the structure is solid, some properties are a headache because of the paperwork wrapped around them. Title problems, unpermitted work, or complicated ownership structures can turn a straightforward sale into a marathon of phone calls with attorneys, lenders, and local officials. From an agent’s perspective, these are the listings where you do three times the work for the same commission, and you still might watch the deal collapse at the closing table because a bank lawyer finds something everyone else missed.

Risk specialists warn that Title issues can derail a closing if it turns out the seller is not the rightful owner or if a government agency or bank has a claim on the property, which can force delays or cancellations while the parties sort out who actually has the right to sell. Separate guidance on red flags in transactions explains that title complications, liens, or complex ownership structures are exactly the kind of problems that can surface late and jeopardize the entire deal, as outlined in an Aug overview of closing risks. Then there is unpermitted work: mortgage experts note that Mortgage lenders can demand repayment if they discover serious unpermitted changes, and that Many lenders hesitate to finance homes with that kind of history at all, because it can affect the property’s value and even violate loan terms. When you stack those issues together, you get the kind of listing that agents quietly hope lands in someone else’s lap.

The emotionally attached, DIY or “I know better” seller

The last category is not really about the house at all, it is about the person who owns it. Realtors talk openly about how draining it is to work with sellers who insist on staying home for every showing, argue with feedback, or refuse basic staging advice. When you are convinced your wood paneling is sacred, your bright purple accent wall is “fun,” or your price is non‑negotiable because of what you “need to get,” you are setting your agent up for a fight with every buyer who walks through the door. That kind of emotional attachment can turn even a great property into a slow, awkward sale.

Like Fix It Homestead’s content? Be sure to follow us.

Here’s more from us:

• I made Joanna Gaines’s Friendsgiving casserole and here is what I would keep
• Pump Shotguns That Jam the Moment You Actually Need Them
• The First 5 Things Guests Notice About Your Living Room at Christmas
• What Caliber Works Best for Groundhogs, Armadillos, and Other Digging Pests?
• Rifles worth keeping by the back door on any rural property

*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.