This renovation choice keeps voiding insurance coverage

Your biggest insurance risk in a renovation is not the sledgehammer or the scaffolding. It is starting major work without looping in the company that insures your house. That single choice, repeated in kitchens, basements, and backyards every weekend, is what keeps voiding coverage and turning routine claims into expensive personal bills.

If you are planning to knock down walls, add a rental suite, or install a pool, your insurer expects to hear about it before the dust starts to fly. When you skip that step, you are quietly changing the deal you signed, and the fine print gives your provider wide latitude to cancel a policy, deny a claim, or pay only a fraction of what you thought was protected.

The renovation decision that quietly cancels your safety net

The most common way you put your home insurance at risk is by beginning substantial renovations without telling your insurer. Any time you make major changes to the structure, layout, or use of your home, you are altering the risk profile that underpins your policy. If you go ahead without disclosure, you are effectively asking the company to insure a different property than the one it priced, which is a textbook reason for a claim to be rejected or a policy to be cancelled.

Specialists warn that anytime you make to your home and fail to report them, you create grounds for your policy being voided. Another advisory is blunt that Beginning Renovations Without projects can lead to a refusal to cover damages that occur during construction. The pattern is consistent: insurers treat undisclosed work as a material misrepresentation, and they are contractually allowed to walk away from losses that stem from it.

Why insurers care so much about “material change”

From your perspective, a renovation is about comfort and value. From your insurer’s perspective, it is a spike in both hazard and potential payout. Demolition, open wiring, temporary supports, and unfamiliar tradespeople all increase the odds of fire, water damage, or injury. If you add square footage, finish a basement, or upgrade finishes, you also increase what it would cost to rebuild, which means the original premium no longer matches the actual exposure.

Guidance for home renovations that stresses that projects like additions, kitchen overhauls, or finished attics can change the replacement value of your home and the liability you present. Another resource on you’re planning a remodel notes that you may need to adjust coverage limits so the policy still reflects the true cost to rebuild. When you do not report those shifts, you are asking the insurer to insure more risk for the same price, and the contract gives them remedies if something goes wrong during that gap.

Major projects that trigger extra coverage or voids

Not every coat of paint needs a phone call, but certain categories of work almost always demand a policy review. Large structural changes, such as removing load bearing walls, expanding the footprint, or adding a second story, can push your home into a different risk class. So can converting a garage, building a rental suite, or turning part of your home into a business space, because those changes alter how often the property is occupied and who is on site.

Legal analysis of renovation disputes notes that additional risk, you may need to Pay a Builder Risk Premium or secure a separate Builder Risk Premium policy while work is underway. Consumer guidance on Major renovations is clear that big projects can significantly affect your existing coverage and may even void it in some cases unless you increase your policy limits or add temporary protection. If you ignore those requirements and a fire, collapse, or theft occurs mid project, the insurer can argue that the loss falls outside the scope of the original contract.

Additions, suites, and the 80% rule problem

Adding living space is one of the most popular ways to boost a home’s value, but it is also where you are most likely to fall foul of technical coverage rules. When you finish a basement, build an extension, or create a rental unit, you are not just changing square footage, you are changing occupancy, escape routes, and potential liability. If you do not adjust your policy, you can end up underinsured even if the insurer does not fully cancel the contract.

One Canadian advisory urges you to Inform Your Insurance or Adding a Suite to Your Home so they can confirm you are adequately covered. Another explanation of the 80% rule states the policy must cover at least 80% of the property’s total replacement cost, which would be the amount that it would cost to rebuild the house from the ground up. If you add a suite or extension and never update the insured value, you can slip below that 80% threshold and face a reduced payout on a partial loss, even if the insurer does not formally void the policy.

Pools, decks, and other liability magnets

Some renovations do not change your walls at all but still transform your risk profile. Installing a pool, building a large deck, or adding a hot tub introduces obvious injury hazards and, in the insurer’s eyes, a higher chance of lawsuits. If you go ahead without disclosing these features, you are not just risking property coverage, you are also testing the limits of your liability protection.

Guidance on Installing a Pool notes that Pools are another popular renovation project, but they can significantly change how much coverage you need because of drowning and slip risks. A separate overview of Renovations that increase the home’s value or liability, like pools or additions, explains that these will usually raise your premium. If you install a pool, skip the disclosure, and a guest is injured, your insurer can argue that you failed to report a major liability change and either cap or deny the claim.

DIY shortcuts, unlicensed crews, and claim denials

How you renovate matters almost as much as what you renovate. When you take on complex work yourself or hire unlicensed contractors to save money, you are not just gambling with building quality, you are also testing your insurer’s patience. Policies often assume that electrical, structural, and gas work will be done by qualified professionals who follow code and carry their own coverage.

One warning on DIY Your Renovations notes that trying to handle major projects yourself can be dangerous and may give insurers a reason to reject claims if something goes wrong. Another breakdown of renovation pitfalls explains that Now if you hire a contractor who lacks proper liability and workers’ compensation insurance, your own insurer may refuse to pay out the claim. In practice, that can leave you personally responsible for injuries on site or for damage caused by shoddy work.

Vacant homes, contractors on site, and missing protections

Renovations often mean your home is partially vacant or full of people who do not live there, and both situations can strain a standard policy. Many contracts limit coverage when a property is unoccupied for an extended period, because empty homes are more vulnerable to vandalism, unnoticed leaks, or fires. At the same time, bringing in trades introduces new liability exposures that your regular homeowner policy may not fully address.

One advisory points out that Homeowners often assume their current insurance automatically covers renovation related risks, while in reality they may need to confirm that contractors carry their own liability and workers’ compensation insurance. Another guide to renovation insurance highlights Common exclusions in home renovation insurance, including Pre existing damage and other issues that are not covered if something goes wrong. If you assume your standard policy will stretch to cover vacant periods, contractor injuries, and pre existing defects, you may discover those gaps only after a claim is denied.

The conversation you keep postponing with your insurer

Most of the worst outcomes are avoidable if you talk to your insurer before work begins. That conversation is where you confirm whether you need a rider, a temporary construction policy, or higher limits, and it is also where you document that you disclosed the project. If you skip it, you are leaving your largest asset exposed to a technicality that can surface years later, long after the dust sheets are gone.

One renovation checklist notes that Sep advice is to talk to your agent BEFORE renovations begin so you can avoid mistakes that lead to denied claims. Another consumer explainer reports that Insurance Information Institute recommends contacting your insurance company before your project starts and increasing coverage to reflect the upcoming changes to your home. When you treat that call as a standard part of planning, alongside permits and contractor bids, you dramatically reduce the odds that a future claim will be contested on the grounds of non disclosure.

How to renovate without losing coverage

Protecting your policy while you renovate comes down to a few disciplined habits. You should notify your insurer early, provide clear details about the scope and cost of the work, and ask directly whether the project triggers any special conditions. You should also confirm that your contractor carries adequate coverage and that any vacancy or occupancy changes are documented, especially if you will be out of the home for weeks at a time.

Australian guidance that applies broadly urges you to Notify Your Insurer policies require you to tell them about your home renovation so they can adjust terms. Another renovation overview explains that Any time you make a significant update to your house, you need to make sure it is up to code and that your coverage is updated to cover all your bases. Even informal advice threads echo the same point, with one commenter urging you to Read your policy because Most state that you must disclose any improvement over $500 within a set period or risk problems at claim time.

When insurers say no anyway

Even when you think you have done everything right, you can still run into a denial if the insurer believes you misrepresented something or failed to meet a condition. That is where the details of your policy, your emails, and your permits matter. If you can show that you disclosed the project, followed code, and hired properly insured professionals, you are in a stronger position to challenge a refusal or negotiate a settlement.

One explainer on renovation insurance notes that Here are exclusions like Pre existing damage that can still cause issues if something goes wrong, even with coverage in place. A separate video case study describes Dave, a homeowner in Colorado Springs, who learned how quickly a company can cancel a policy when it believes the risk has changed without proper notice. If you find yourself in that position, you may need legal advice, but the best defense is still the simplest: disclose early, document everything, and treat your insurer as another critical stakeholder in your renovation, not an afterthought once the work is done.

Like Fix It Homestead’s content? Be sure to follow us.

Here’s more from us:

• I made Joanna Gaines’s Friendsgiving casserole and here is what I would keep
• Pump Shotguns That Jam the Moment You Actually Need Them
• The First 5 Things Guests Notice About Your Living Room at Christmas
• What Caliber Works Best for Groundhogs, Armadillos, and Other Digging Pests?
• Rifles worth keeping by the back door on any rural property

*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.