Shotguns that hate cheap shells and make you regret stocking bulk ammo

Cheap shotgun shells look like a bargain until your gun starts choking on them just when you need it to run. If you rely on bulk low-brass loads for training, home defense drills, or competition practice, some platforms will punish that decision with constant short-stroking, failures to eject, and mangled hulls. Understanding which designs are finicky, why they struggle, and how to work around those limitations keeps you from turning a pallet of discount ammo into an expensive pile of frustration.

Why bargain shells expose a shotgun’s weak spots

When you feed a shotgun the weakest ammunition in your stash, you are really stress testing its operating system, springs, and tolerances. Low-cost shells often use inconsistent powder charges, softer hulls, and less robust crimps, which can all sap the energy needed to cycle a semi-auto or make extraction harder in any action. Guidance on target loads explicitly warns that some light shells simply do not have enough power to run a self-loader correctly, which is exactly when you start seeing failures to feed or the bolt stopping short of full lockup.

Cheap ammunition also magnifies basic reliability sins that better loads can mask. A detailed breakdown of common stoppages notes that Using low-quality ammo opens the door to misfires, deformed cases, and delayed ignition, any of which can derail a semi-auto’s timing. When you combine that with the reality that, as one gunsmithing guide puts it, a dirty firearm is often the single biggest cause of malfunctions, especially in guns that vent fouling into the action by using a gas system, you get a perfect storm: underpowered shells, carbon buildup, and marginal springs all conspiring to make you regret buying the cheapest case on the shelf.

Benelli M2: inertia perfection, until you go too light

The Benelli M2 has a reputation as a workhorse, but its inertia system is brutally honest about weak ammo. Owners who try to break in a new M2 Tactical with very soft loads often report that the bolt simply does not travel far enough to eject and feed reliably. One shooter described running 100 rounds of low-brass dove loads through a new gun and seeing spent hulls hang up after they cleared the chamber, a classic sign that the recoil impulse is marginal for the system. With full-power buckshot or slugs the same gun may feel flawless, which can trick you into blaming the shells rather than recognizing that the platform is tuned for a certain energy floor.

Digging into user troubleshooting shows how sensitive the M2 can be to both ammo and setup. In one detailed thread, a poster walks through diagnosing a cycling problem by watching what the bolt carrier does during recoil, explaining that You are looking to see whether it is fully compressing the recoil spring or stopping short as the gun gets dirtier. Another owner, in a discussion marked by the phrase Posted April, describes an M2 that struggles to cycle certain shells and only settles down after a steady diet of heavier loads for about a month of those shells. If you stockpile ultra-soft bulk ammo expecting an M2 to run it out of the box, you are betting against the design’s physics.

Gas guns that sulk on low-brass bulk packs

Gas-operated shotguns are often sold as the softer shooting, more forgiving alternative to inertia guns, but they are not immune to cheap-shell drama. Light loads may not generate enough pressure to drive the piston and action bars through their full stroke, especially if the ports are tuned for heavier hunting or defensive ammunition. A short video on why semi-automatic shotguns do not cycle reliably out of the box points out that gas guns tend to be less finicky than inertia designs, yet both can stumble when you drop below the power level they were built around.

Real-world examples show how this plays out. A detailed teardown of a Stoeger M3000 by a channel introducing itself with “what’s up everybody welcome to Tactical Fellowship the purpose of today’s video” walks through bad extraction and weak cycling that appear when the gun is fed softer loads and has not been tuned. Another video from a shop greeting viewers with “hey what’s going on guys welcome back to Reynolds Outdoors” explains that some Browning and Winchester gas guns that are not cycling often need their gas systems cleaned or adjusted to match the ammunition. If your bulk purchase is a pallet of low-brass target shells, a gas gun that was set up for stout field loads can feel like it “hates” that ammo until you either retune it or step up the power.

Low brass, high brass, and why the label misleads you

Many shooters assume that “high brass” automatically means powerful and “low brass” means weak, then blame their shotgun when a box of bargain low-brass loads will not cycle. In reality, the height of the metal on the hull is mostly cosmetic in modern ammunition and does not guarantee a specific pressure or velocity. Shot pattern expert Jimmy Mueller at Muller Choke Tubes walks through this misconception, explaining that manufacturers can and do load powerful shells with low brass and mild shells with higher brass, so you have to read the payload and velocity numbers instead of trusting the rim height.

The way your shotgun interacts with different hulls and crimps matters more than the marketing label. A technical overview of low brass vs high brass notes that break-action designs such as double-barreled shotguns have few issues extracting or ejecting either style, because you are providing the mechanical leverage. Semi-autos and pumps, by contrast, can be picky about certain hulls, especially when the combination of chamber finish, extractor tension, and shell construction makes sticky extraction more likely. If you fill your shelves with the cheapest low-brass shells you can find, you may discover that your gun’s preferences have nothing to do with brass height and everything to do with how those hulls behave under pressure.

When mag-fed shotguns punish long-term bulk storage

Mag-fed shotguns promise fast reloads and detachable magazines, which sounds ideal when you are stacking cases of discount ammo. The catch is that plastic hulls do not love being compressed in a box magazine for months at a time. A discussion among owners of these platforms highlights that shells will deform, whether they are high or low brass, when left under spring pressure, and that this happens in both magazines and tubes. One shooter on a thread about avoiding the main drawback of mag-fed shotguns notes that this is why you keep fresh ammo in rotation instead of leaving the same rounds loaded indefinitely.

Deformed hulls are especially unforgiving in designs that already have tight feed geometry. A slightly bulged shell that might still chamber in a pump can nose-dive or hang up on the feed ramp in a mag-fed semi-auto, turning your bulk purchase into a reliability liability. When you combine that with the fact that some semi-autos are already sensitive to low-brass bargain loads, as highlighted in coverage that opens with the line Not all shotguns handle bargain-bin ammunition the same way and that Some semi-autos will choke on low-brass loads, you get a platform that can be doubly punishing if you stockpile the wrong shells and then leave them loaded for too long.

Autoloaders versus pumps: who really tolerates trash ammo?

Conventional wisdom says pumps will eat anything and semi-autos are picky, but the reality is more nuanced when you start feeding them the cheapest shells you can buy. A hunting-focused breakdown of shotgun types notes under the heading Autoloader Cons Versatility that, due to the various cycling systems in semi-auto shotguns, adjustments must be made to most of them to run different loads and shell lengths. That is especially true at the low end of the power spectrum, where a light 1-ounce target load may not generate enough recoil or gas to cycle a gun that was tuned around heavy waterfowl or turkey shells.

Pumps and break-actions, by contrast, are far less sensitive to power level, which is why they are often recommended for shooters who plan to live on bulk packs. The same analysis points out that Due to their manual operation, pumps can handle a wide range of loads without adjustment, and break actions have almost no cycling issues at all. Yet even pumps can stumble on bargain shells if the hulls are soft enough to swell or the crimps are sloppy, a point echoed in coverage of shotguns that happily eat cheap ammo while noting that even some pumps can struggle with certain low-brass loads. If you want to stockpile the very bottom tier of shells, a simple action gives you the widest margin for error.

Dirty guns, weak shells, and the jam spiral

Cheap shells are often dirtier, and that fouling compounds every other reliability problem. A gunsmith writing about chronic stoppages argues that, in their opinion, the single most common reason for malfunctions is a dirty firearm, and that they have fixed most jam complaints simply by cleaning the gun, especially in designs that vent gas into the action. That insight, laid out in a piece on gun jams, is magnified when you are burning through bulk ammo that leaves heavy residue in the ports, piston, and chamber.

Once fouling builds up, underpowered shells that were barely cycling a clean gun may stop working altogether. A semi-auto that runs your bargain loads for the first few boxes can start short-stroking as carbon accumulates, especially in gas systems that already have small ports or marginal springs. That is why some reliability-focused trainers emphasize that Most semi-auto shotguns are not very reliable by modern standards or they only run with a narrow band of ammo used for training. If you insist on feeding your gun the dirtiest, softest shells you can find, you have to be more disciplined about cleaning and spring maintenance than the shooter who buys premium loads.

Exotic builds and suppressed shotguns on bargain diets

Specialty shotguns, especially suppressed or ultra-compact builds, add another layer of complexity when you start experimenting with cheap ammo. A video showcasing what it calls the Worlds Most Compact Suppressed Shotgun opens with “a oh holy guacamole is this not the craziest shotgun you’ve ever seen in your entire life,” and the engineering behind that kind of build often depends on very specific pressure curves. Suppressors can increase backpressure and change how gas-operated systems cycle, which means a load that barely runs in a standard gun might either fail to cycle or overdrive the action once you add a can.

When you pair that sensitivity with the inconsistent performance of bargain shells, reliability becomes a moving target. Some suppressed shotguns are tuned around particular buckshot or slug loads and may not function at all with the lightest target shells, a limitation that is easy to forget when you are staring at a sale on bulk low-brass ammo. If you are investing in exotic platforms, from integrally suppressed pumps to ultra-short semi-autos, you should treat ammunition choice as part of the system rather than an afterthought, and test any cheap load thoroughly before you commit to stacking it deep.

How to buy bulk without sabotaging your shotgun

None of this means you have to abandon the idea of buying in bulk, only that you need a more disciplined approach. Start by choosing loads that are known to cycle your specific gun, then look for those exact specs when you shop for cases instead of chasing the lowest price per shell. A guide to shotgun shells for target practice stresses that, if you are running a semi-auto, you must make sure the shells you choose have enough power to cycle the action, or they simply will not run correctly. That advice is even more important if your platform is an inertia gun like the Benelli M2 or a gas gun tuned for heavy hunting loads.

Once you have a reliable load, buy smart and store smart. Rotate ammunition that lives in magazines or tubes so hulls do not deform, especially in mag-fed shotguns where long-term compression can cause feeding issues. Pay attention to how your gun behaves as it gets dirty, and remember that cheap shells may require more frequent cleaning to maintain the same reliability. If you want a shotgun that shrugs off bargain ammo, look at the models highlighted in coverage of shotguns that eat cheap shells without missing a beat, then pattern and stress test your chosen bulk load until you are confident it will not turn on you when it matters.

Like Fix It Homestead’s content? Be sure to follow us.

Here’s more from us:

• I made Joanna Gaines’s Friendsgiving casserole and here is what I would keep
• Pump Shotguns That Jam the Moment You Actually Need Them
• The First 5 Things Guests Notice About Your Living Room at Christmas
• What Caliber Works Best for Groundhogs, Armadillos, and Other Digging Pests?
• Rifles worth keeping by the back door on any rural property

*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.